Reactions to Various Rape Stories in KSA that were published in the news
by: Joseph Henry B. Espiritu
October 15, 2016
Before we tackle rape cases in Saudi Arabia, we must first learn these three categories:
Real Rape cases – should come in the provisions of Hirabah for inflicting bodily harm and assault. Punishment should be death under ‘hudud’ but since there is a victim, this falls under ‘Qisas’. In Qisas, the accused can only be spared from the death penalty through ‘tanazul’ (forgiveness) from the victim or the victim’s family. The victim or the victim’s family has the right to ask for ‘diyaa’ (compensation or blood money) from the accused.
Rape with Consent, immorality, adultery and fornication – are classified as ‘zina’ (illicit affair). Real rape victim might fall into this category due to the following failures; late filing of complaints, absence of medical report and no visible signs of struggle. The complainant (victim) is guilty of ‘zina’ if it is proven that she has a relationship with the rapist. There are no private rights or blood money to be received by the victim.
False Rape Accusations (‘qadhf’ or slander) – are not ‘qisas’ but are considered as ‘hudud’. These are punishable by jail terms, accompanied with 80 or more lashes to the guilty party. Many women always use the excuse “RAPED by their employer” as their alibi if they want to go home after many years of being undocumented. They prefer to tell their stories to the media rather than to the police or to their embassies. In most cases they will be repatriated with children they bore from their boyfriends. Sad to say, most of them were married to other men before.
Now let us talk about the rape cases that were published in the online news lately.
1. Reaction to: “OFW Rights Group Seeks Repatriation of Rape Victims”, written by Rudy Estimo
Rape is a very serious allegation. The writer should evaluate first if these rape accusations are all true before publishing his story in a widely-read newspaper.
What did these women do right after they escaped? Did they file a case against their employer for rape? Did they seek help from the Philippine embassy? No, they worked outside, had boyfriends and enjoyed the freedom that they could not avail while in their employer’s house. Later, they got pregnant, sought help from their embassy and requested to stay in the shelter to avoid detention.
Who are the fathers of these children? Are the Saudi employers or the boyfriends whom they lived with after they had escaped from their employer’s house?
Of the ten mothers, only one had claimed that her child’s father is a Saudi. The rest of the children’s fathers were identified to be Bangladeshis, Egyptians and mostly were Filipinos; yet all of them claimed that they were raped by their employers?
Did they file a case against the fathers of these kids? No, in fact these men are still supporting these women financially while the latter and their children are staying in the shelter!
One of the mothers insisted that the father of her child is a Saudi. Did she file a case right away? No, she ran away and worked outside for another employer. She claimed that she never knew that she was pregnant. She only sought help from the embassy when she was about to deliver the baby. If a housemaid got pregnant and it is proven that her employer is the father, then that would be considered a rape case (for the reason that the housemaid is always deprived of the act to defend herself while staying in her employer’s house).
Almost three years ago, I suggested to her that she must submit her son for DNA testing. The result would then be compared to the DNA of her Saudi employer. If it is proven that the employer is the father of the child, then her employer will go to jail and she can get a compensation for moral and material damages. However if it is proven that the employer is not the father then she is guilty of “false accusation” and immorality. She then told me that she would prefer to go home than to undergo a DNA test and file a case.
False accusation or slander (‘qadhf’) is a criminal offense in Saudi Arabia, and it punishable by jail terms and lashes. Immorality (‘zina’) and prostitution (‘bighaa’) are also punishable by jail term and 100 lashes. These are under hudud punishments which the penalties are fixed. Who are the false accusers here in this news report?
Mr. Estimo , the writer of the Arab News article, Mr. Monterona of Migrante International and the mothers of these children
Rape happens anywhere and Saudi Arabia is not an exception. Here, we have victims of real rape cases who are still fighting for their rights. They have proofs, signs of struggles and medical reports. They filed cases against the rapists and the victims are now waiting for justice.
Those fake rape claims won’t help the situation of the REAL rape victims. If a REAL rape did happen, then who will believe us if 99 percent of those who claimed to have been raped are not telling the truth?
Suggestions for Resolutions: Staying in the shelter for three years is a long wait for these mothers and children to be repatriated. The Philippine Ambassador should have made a personal appeal to the Governor of Saudi Arabia Prince Salman, asking the good Emir for humanitarian consideration to repatriate the mothers and their children.
Recommendations: THE PHILIPPINE GOVERNMENT MUST STOP SENDING FILIPINA WORKERS TO WORK AS DOMESTIC WORKERS ABROAD. Most of the distressed women are domestic workers. Most of these women who claimed to have been raped are domestic workers. Most of these women who ran away and got pregnant
by their boyfriends are domestic workers. Besides, in the Middle East, the domestic workers are not included in the Labor laws. They are overworked without day-off and stayed in their employer’s house, 7 days a week. Most of them are not allowed to have a mobile phone. When a domestic worker is abused or maltreated by her employer, it would be too late for our embassy and even the authorities to respond.
2. Reactions to: “Rape Victim Leaves for Philippines”, written by Rudy Estimo (link:http://arabnews.com/saudiarabia/article59734.ece)
This is another shallow story about rape and the writer just relied mostly on the account of one party. The information could have been taken from the alleged victim or from just a gossiper.
Since the writer had mentioned about the intervention of the police and the Philippine Consulate, he should have tried to get a statement from at least one of these offices. He failed to do that and he just wrote his story as if the rape really had happened. Excerpt from the said article “The suspect did not deny the charge and was asked to pay SR5, 000 and issue an exit visa for the maid’s repatriation.”
1. If the employer had admitted to the rape then what was the recommendation of the police investigator or the prosecutor’s office for public action? How many years of jail term and how many lashes?
2. Is the amount 5,000Sr given to the housemaid was for moral compensation of the rape or for the back wages? Committing ‘al zina’ (adultery, immorality) and ‘hiraba’ (real rape and other bodily harm) are hudud crimes. The writer should have asked the police why the employer was spared from punishments of public actions if he admitted the rape.
I sent an email to Consul General Ezzedin Tago about this story and he replied:
From: Ezzedin Tago
Subject: Resending: Reaction/Inquiry: Arabnews – Filipina rape victim in Saudi flies home
To: “Joseph Henry B. Espiritu”
Date: Friday, June 4, 2010, 8:17 AM Joseph,
I was out of Saudi Arabia for official business and just returned last night. As a general rule, we don’t issue press releases on cases of rape. I agree that we should be asked before the consulate is mentioned in any article. Unfortunately, some in the media do not accord the consulate the right of reply to many of these statements. I will check out the background of this case and get back to you.
If it is true that the housemaid had contacted the Philippine Consulate coordinator of the area, then the coordinator should not advise the housemaid to escape. Instead, the Philippine Consulate should send their officers to file the complaints directly to the nearest Police Station’s Civil Rights Department (‘hukok’). The police would invite the employer. The employer would be advised to bring his housemaid to the Police Station. An investigation must be conducted in the presence of the employer, the housemaid and the officers of the consulate.
Rudy Estimo must learn how to be a responsible writer. He must be equipped with the knowledge of the laws and procedures before writing about a rape case. We have real rape victims who are still seeking justice in the criminal court. They are the ones who are hurt by these fake rape stories. It is also not fair to destroy the reputation of a country and its people by an invalidated rape story such as this.
I believe in the freedom of expression. I believe in the freedom of the press but we must all be cautious that we must not hurt the feelings of innocent people.
Recommendations: Journalists, news reporters and NGOs must have the knowledge of the laws and procedures before writing or reporting a story about rape.
The Philippine Government must educate the officers of our consulate and embassy about the laws and procedures of Saudi Arabia before sending them here.
Again, The Philippine Government must stop sending Filipina workers to work as domestic workers abroad. Our women can do better than being housemaids in foreign lands.
3. Reactions to: “Filipino Schoolteacher Claims She Was Raped by Parent”, written by Rudy Estimo. (Link: http://arabnews.com/saudiarabia/article84254.ece)
There are so many loopholes in this rape story which makes it look as if it’s from a tabloid newspaper. The writer only relied from the information supplied to him by the group Migrante. He could have asked for information from the Philippine Embassy where the woman’s complaint was filed.
We also had conducted our investigation about this story and we found out that this is a self inflicted case. A case caused by stupidity, adultery and immorality.
The sad thing about this story is that all persons involved were all Filipinos. The man is working in a Government hospital here in Riyadh. The woman was working as a teacher in a Private Philippine School, also in Riyadh. The woman has another boyfriend who is an officer of Migrante Group.
During her free time (mostly at night), the Filipina admitted that she conducted tutorial lessons to the child of the Filipino. The tutorial lessons were conducted in the man’s house. That is illegal in Saudi Arabia and they can be charged with zina (adultery, immorality and prostitution). On the other hand, the man claimed that the Filipina teacher was his girlfriend.
The Migrante boyfriend got jealous and told the Filipina teacher that the man allegedly posted nude photos of her in Facebook website. The woman was so worried that this scandal might reach to her real husband’s knowledge.
With the help of Migrante, the Filipina went to the Philippine Embassy and filed her complaint against the Filipino. The Philippine Embassy officer advised the two to settle their misunderstanding by themselves. It is not rape but adultery if the two had illicit relationship. Besides, the alleged rape had happened a long time before the woman decided to file her complaints.
Discontented by the Philippine Embassy’s advice, Migrante resorted to tap the writer of Arabnews to write the story of the Filipina. On July 15, 2010, the story “Filipino Schoolteacher Claims She Was Raped by Parent” was published.
Rudy Estimo should have verified the story by asking for more information from the Philippine Embassy or from the alleged rapist.
The Filipina could use this Arabnews story as a proof to her husband that she was really raped. She already left Saudi Arabia but her story did not end there. Migrante had spammed a hate email against the Filipino with the subject “Manyakis ng Riyadh (Sex Maniac of Riyadh)”. They wrote almost the complete information of the Filipino and attached his photos in that email. The email spread rapidly that there is no chance for the Filipino to defend himself. His child has stopped going school because of embarrassment.
Migrante did not stop their way of getting justice. They claimed to have submitted a complaint letter to the administration of the hospital where the Filipino works. Rudy Estimo of Arabnews then wrote this article, “Filipino Rape Victim Complains to Attacker’s Employer”.
And Migrante still did not stop there. They spread the alleged nude photos of the lovers in the emails to prove that their allegations against the Filipino are all true.
Recommendation: Most Filipinos know that Migrante is just an unruly group who always resort to lies just to get the attention from the media, and to attack the Philippine Government no matter what, possibly just to get funding from their donors. I should not waste my time talking against Migrante but they have gone too far that they are already a threat to the Filipino workers in Saudi Arabia.
4. Now, I need your reactions to the following articles “OFW Group to Probe Pinay’s Saudi Rape tale – RP Envoy Scores Pinay over False Rape Claim”
Note: I had an open communication with the officers of our Embassy when they went to Qatif to rescue this Filipina. When they were in the Police Station, I kept talking to Tom and Zailon through our mobile phones and I listened to every conversation.
I can attest that it is not true that Clarita did not receive her salary. She had an ATM card where she kept her salary as savings. The employer told Tom and Zailon that Clarita requested to open a bank account because she wanted to save her salary here.
Employer: How much is your money now in your savings?
Clarita: 3900 Riyals Baba.
Employer: When was the last time you checked your savings (ATM card)?
Clarita: Two weeks ago Baba. (That means she was free to go out?)
Employer: I deposited your salary for this month last week. It is now 4600SR.
They then went to the bank to withdraw Clarita’s salary and to close the account. When the employer left, I told Tom to ask Clarita if she was really raped and that if it was true that she was videotaped by four men. She answered that she was not raped and that it was just a creation of her imagination because she wanted to go home. Tom and Zailon promised to Clarita that the embassy would help her fight for justice if she really was raped but Clarita insisted that it was just from her imagination.
This Filipina admitted that she didn’t want to finish her contract; thus she decided to use the story about rape. When asked about the alleged video, she answered that it was just also a creation of her imagination.
I told Tom, that my suspicion was that this Filipina had a boyfriend and most probably she was pregnant; that she was afraid of the punishment; and that she could use the rape story for her husband to accept her back. I asked Tom to bring the lady for medical checkup.
Tom told me that he also had the same suspicion but the medical checkup might not help Clarita. So, I suggested Tom to let Clarita sign an undertaking that she was not really raped and that she just wanted to go home. Tom answered that they would do that but not in the police station or she might be punished for slander.
Remember, false accusation or slander is a ‘hudud’ crime. So, I told Tom to ask the lady if she was willing to sign an undertaking that she was not really raped. The Filipina answered, yes. The employer came back and gave Clarita 4000 Philippine Pesos.
Employer: I know that your house is far from Manila, please accept this amount that you can use to travel home.
Clarita: No, no Baba, I won’t accept that. That is too much.
Tom: Tanggapin mo yan. (Take it!)
Clarita: Thank you Baba. I won’t forget you; everyone in your family is so good to me.
Few days later this was the news from Migrante, “Group Says Raped OFW Forced to Do A Retraction”
5. Again, I need your reaction to this Article “Probe Case of Jailed OFW Rape Victim in Saudi”
Note: The alleged rape victim and a Bangladeshi national were caught in the laboratory doing an immoral act. Neri claimed that she was raped even if all of their co-workers testified that Neri and the Bangladeshi had a relationship. It was later found out that the Neri was already four months pregnant when she was arrested for immorality case. Still, Neri insisted that she was raped.
6. Here is the rape news from Migrante, for your reaction OFWs seek probe on abduction-rape of 4 RP nurses in Saudi.
and you may find the link below the response from our Embassy: No Verification Yet on Alleged Rape of 4 Filipina Nurses in Saudi – RP Embassy
Patnubay Reaction: If this was true, then expect that there should be complaints from the families of these alleged rape victims. That will never happen because this is another fake rape story that was fabricated by a militant group named Migrante.
These Migrante officers in Saudi Arabia, John Leonard Monterona (Hail), Eric Jocson (Riyadh), Mario Bien (Riyadh) and Andrew Ociones (Jeddah) must stop fabricating and spreading these fake rape stories.
7. Here is another fabricated rape story
(The news above was already removed by GMANews after the Philippine Embassy in Riyadh issued their Press Release)
Arabnews Link: https://www.arabnews.com/node/361467
As usual, Migrante plus Rudy Estimo equals a fake rape story.
And here is the response from the Philippine Embassy (continued from previous page)
Reactions Drafted By
Joseph Henry B. Espiritu
For Truth, Fairness and Justice
We in Patnubay, thank our Saudi lawyers and fellow advocates who are helping us in fighting for the rights of those real rape victims.